Nowadays, such new terminology as perimeter weighted forged
irons, cast-blade, and constant MOI (moment of inertia) are often
seen and somehow catch our eyes. Nonetheless, they are nothing
but confusing. This page will explain such terms especially with
their relationship to the trends in the marketplace, in
addition to physics and mechanisms of irons.
There are two main and noticeable market segments in the market
of irons: 1) forged irons represented by such products as
Mizuno
T-Zoid
and
Ben
Hogan Apex
;
and 2) cast irons represented by products like
Ping
i Series
and
Callaway
irons.

One
of the most notable recent trends in the irons market is
perimeter
weight forged irons, which are manufactured by the double
or triple forging method. As opposed to the traditional chromium
plating finish, perimeter weight forged irons are often
nickel
plated for a softer feel (see "
Materials"
for details). Previously, most recreational golfers assumed that
the term "forged" was synonymous with "blade",
and were not interested in using them. However, today there are
many forged models that feature cavities and slightly larger sized
club-heads. This gives a wider range of players the opportunity
to experience the softer feel of forged irons, while having the
added forgiveness of cast irons.

Another
noticeable trend in the market is the
multi-metal design for cast irons with a
lower
center of gravity (CG). This approach is employed by many
manufacturers, but most notably by
Callaway with its
HawkEye
Tungsten Injected Titanium Irons
and
Taylor
Made FireSole Irons
.
Callaway claims that its new proprietary weighting system allows
its engineers to create a center of gravity lower than any of
the company's previous iron models. The Hawk Eye 5-iron has a
center of gravity that is approximately 24 percent lower than
the other low CG models like the Great Big Bertha
Tungsten-Titanium Irons or Big Bertha X-12 Irons. The weighting
system makes its CG very low.
Production Method
- Irons are manufactured either by investment casting or forging.
The casting process, which is used for the majority of irons produced
today, is the "lost wax method". This method involves
the creation of male molds first made of wax to create the female
molds which later are filled with molten metal. Typically, golf
iron heads are casted in
17-4 or
431 stainless steel. In contrast, forged irons are forged
from a solid piece of soft carbon steel (
mild
steel) and then finished by hand. On average, mainly due to
hand finish forged irons tend to be less consistent and more expensive.
Materials
- Although the use of titanium has proven to be valuable in the
design of drivers and some fairway woods, it is not the case in
irons. Because of the fact that the club-head of irons can be
much heavier than that of drivers, titanium proved to be rather
pointless, unless it is used in combination with heavier, more
dense metals. Consequently, stainless steel still remains the
material of choice for most iron manufacturers. Carbon steel is
also still used by several companies (both for forgings and castings)
because of its forming capability and superior feel characteristics.
Nickel is also used for castings, and plating as well, because
of its unique combination of strength and softness (see "
Materials"
for more information).
Flow Design - You may
have heard of a terminology "flow design", which appears
to be used for changing or adjusting the club-head or shaft design
in accordance with the flow of clubs -- from a short iron to the
middle and then to long irons. Obviously, as you see in the table
below, any set of clubs employs the "flow design" concept
-- the shaft length, loft, lie angle were all changed in accordance
with the flow of clubs. But, often such specs as
shaft weight, kick-point,
and sometimes like swing-weight
are not variables. The flow design incorporates factors normally
considered as non-variables in order to optimize the performance.
Constant
MOI (Moment of Inertia), for example, is one of such concepts,
but it appears to be rather meaningless unless it is coordinated
with other factors, and particularly if you don't know what MOI
value is most suitable for you (see "MOI"
for more details).
Sole Design - Sole geometry
is often cited by manufacturers. It is often claimed that an increased
sole camber or a rounded sole reduces turf drag, and therefore
helps improve playability in tough lies. In general, the shorter
the irons, the more bounce. Traditionally, long irons are built
with a slight scoop angle. From a deep rough, the bounced sole
minimize the turf drag, and that is why we are taught to open
the club face under such circumstances.
Shaft Length, Loft and Lie Angle
- The iron sets sold by retailers and pro shops usually consist
of eight irons (3-PW), while most of manufacturers offer from
1-iron through lob wedge. For a complete set, you may have to
buy such clubs as a sand wedge and 2-iron as individual clubs.
The typical shaft length, loft and lie angle of a forged iron
models are as follows:
Typical
Forged Iron Model Configuration
| |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
6 |
| Shaft
Length |
39.75" |
39.25" |
38.75" |
38.25" |
37.75" |
37.25" |
| Loft
Angle |
15° |
18° |
21° |
24° |
27° |
31° |
| Lie
Angle |
55° |
56° |
57° |
58° |
59° |
60° |
| |
7 |
8 |
9 |
PW |
SW |
| Shaft
Length |
36.75" |
36.25" |
36.00" |
35.75" |
35.50" |
| Loft
Angle |
35° |
39° |
43° |
48° |
56° |
| Lie
Angle |
60.5° |
61° |
61.5° |
62° |
63° |
The technological advancement in the investment casting technology
as well as new material applications to golf equipment have resulted
in clubs with lower
center of gravity and
less loft. The cavity-back and perimeter weighted clubs, therefore,
tend to be less lofted than the specifications of forged irons
shown in the above table. However, it appears that, as average
golfers tend to prefer additional distance for all golf clubs,
many manufacturers started to sell less lofted irons for additional
distance. As a result, the loft of 10 years old 8-iron may be
equivalent to that of today's 9-iron. This makes it necessary
for many golfers to carry three or sometimes even four wedges
in the bag.
Hosel - The design of a hosel influences the torsional
movement of the club. Additional torsional moment, which becomes
available from such designs as
offset hosel,
increases the potential distance with a commensurate loss of accuracy.
The distance between the CG of club-head and the shaft axis as
well as the
gravity
angle are basically determined by hosel. Offset clubs allow
golfers to keep the club-head behind the hands, making it easier
to keep the face closed at impact. For irons, however, since accuracy
is normally more important than additional distance, club designs
to lower the torsional moment (which is calculated as mass times
distance) are rather considered to be beneficial to lower handicap
golfers and professional golfers. (The inset hosel is example
of a technique used to minimize the distance and the torsional
moment.)