You
may not know that the sand wedge is the heaviest club in your
bag, and contrastingly the driver is the lightest. Regardless
if you knew that or not, weight is one of the club's most confusing
specifications. Since the 1930's, golfers have been paying attention
to weight, and using a concept describing the feel of a club's
(dynamic) weight, "swing-weight". In order for you to
understand more about the mechanisms of how a certain club with
different club weight and swing-weight is translated into your
feel, it is imperative to understand what the club weight, including
the swing-weight, and
shaft properties
do to your feel.
Swing-weight (SW): Swing
weight, which is different from the measure of a club's total
(static) weight but rather how that weight is distributed throughout
the club, is a very confusing concept. Technically, SW is determined
by the total weight of a club (club-head, shaft, grip) and the
static balance point. It is determined by a number calculated
by dividing the distance between the grip end and the balance
point minus 14" (14" scale method) by the club total
weight, where D0 is 213.5 inch/ounce. In this system, C means
lighter than D, and D3 is heavier than D0. Theoretically, it could
go as light as A0, and as heavy as F9. (If you would like to buy
a SW scale, it is available from
Golfsmith.)
For many years a SW of D0 was considered ideal for average golfers,
and D2 or D3 for stronger players. This system was developed in
1930's to make or choose the correct golf clubs in terms of feel
of club weight. At the time, and until as recent as the early
1990's, the materials used for club making were limited to steel
and persimmon, and therefore weight distributed throughout the
club is affected mostly by the shaft length and the weight of
club-head.
However, modern golf clubs vary in weight of components such as
grips, shafts and club-heads. In addition, modern golf club
shaft
properties, including flex, kick-point, torque, etc., vary
more significantly than older clubs -- which all contribute to
your feel of a club weight.
In principle, the stiffer the shaft, the lighter the feel. If
you replace steel shafts of your golf clubs with lighter graphite
shafts, the swing-weight should become heavier while the total
weight of the clubs becomes lighter.
Let's take a look at an example. Take a shaft with a grip and
no club-head at the tip, and try to swing it. It should flutter,
and making it difficult for you to control the movement of the
tip. But if you put weight on the tip, it stabilizes and you get
the feel for the control over the tip end. This means that a lighter
club is difficult to control, although it may help increase club-head
speed. It is apparent that you need to have a balance between
controllability and club-head speed.
Taylor Made Burner Bubble debuted in 1994 is probably the first
golf club successfully introduced to the market with a heavy
SW (D8). With a unique shaft geometry and the heavy SW, it changed
the way to make golf clubs in terms of SW. After that, the surge
in
lighter, longer
shafts and
lighter club-head
materials and bigger club-heads further changed the meaning
of "traditional" SW because they changed a club's balance
point and overall weight.
Goldwin's AVDP, for example, employs 13-gram grip and a feather
light shaft together with the aluminum based club-head, resulting
in a super-light driver with a very heavy SW of E2. If the same
club-heads are used for clubs with different shaft weight, the
swing-weight of clubs with lighter shafts (i.e. graphite shafts)
becomes heavier. Although some manufacturers use different club-heads
in weight, many club makers use the same club-heads.
Ping employs the
Thermocomp back-weight
system for the new woods, which comes in a variety of weights
that allows to tune the swing-weight of the woods regardless of
the finished length of the club and/or the shaft weight.
Constant MOI (Moment of Inertia) Technology
- Tommy Armour introduced the
845
evo series irons (
v-25
forged model and
v-31
cast model
),
claiming that the irons are built for a zero-slope constant MOI.
It compares the evo with popular traditional irons having D2 swing-weight
and a positive MOI. The company's explanation goes to the point
- the ultimate combination of stable long irons and workable short
irons - in which it implies that the MOI method is better than
the traditional 14" scale method in terms of the weight balance
of the irons.
MOI (Moment of Inertia) - MOI
is a very difficult concept to understand. Skip this paragraph
if you do not want to become too technical.
According to a dictionary, it is defined "Of a body about
an axis,

,
where
m is the mass of a particle of the body and
r
is its distance from the axis", or "This is similar
to inertia except that it relates to rotating movement rather
than linear movement". The linear movement is the tendency
of an object to remain motionless if at rest and to keep moving
in a straight line if already in motion.
The moment of inertia, however, is the tendency of an object to
resist being accelerated (or decelerated) when it is rotating.
The polar moment of inertia is the rotating movement around a
vertical axis through the center of rotation. It greatly affects
steering and handling response in an automobile. The greater the
length of the axis the greater the polar moment of inertia. By
having the heavy components of a car such as the engine and transmission
between the two front wheels, the polar moment of inertia is low
so that the tires can easily change the direction of the car.
The point is that as the MOI is calculated as mass times the square
of the distance, in order to make a set of MOI matched clubs with
longer and/or lighter shafts, the club-head weight has to become
lighter. There is a very good article regarding this subject from
clubmakers' resource "
What
does swingweight really mean?" by Dave Tutelman.
| Matching
Method |
9-iron
head weight |
Driver
head weight |
| SW
(14" scale) |
284
grams |
195
grams |
| MOI |
284
grams |
180
grams |
(Source: clubmakers' resource "
What
does swingweight really mean?" by Dave Tutelman.)
Despite the fact that the meaning of the
SW in club making has changed, it appears that manufacturers
still use SW as a baseline reference point in club making.
Nevertheless, since there has never been an industry wide
standard, one company's D0 club may not perform or feel like
another's. Therefore, club weight and SW are still important
to your club selection, but only to the extent how you feel
with a particular club with a certain SW.
Lead Tape Adjustment - One
swing weight (SW) point is translated into 1.7 to 2.2 grams
of club-head weight depending on the shaft length, the total
club weight and the balance point. You need less weight for
drivers than irons to change a SW point. In drivers, by placing
a lead tape of roughly 5 grams, the SW changes approximately
3 points (i.e. from D0 to D3) .
A lead tape on your club-head could change not only the SW
but also the CG (center of gravity)
of the club-head and the gravity
angle, which affects the ball trajectory. In order to
adjust the gravity angle for "draw
bias", place a few grams of lead tape on the position
of the left picture, and for "fade bias", place
it on the position indicated in the right picture. There are
a number of occasions you may find lead tape adjustments are
beneficial to improve your game.
The optimal ball trajectory in a rainy day,
for instance, is different because of the minimal carry due
to the wet conditions. Under such conditions, higher ball
trajectories result in longer balls. You may want to place
a lead tape toward the back of the sole so that the club's
CG shifts (lower and deeper) for higher ball trajectories.
Also, you should know that the increase in 3 - 4 grams of
club-head weight in drivers can be offset in terms of the
swing weight by shortening (choking) the shaft length by 1/2
inches.